Blog: Scotland needs economic hope
27th November 2024
by David Gow, DHI Trustee
"Fings can only get worse," warned PM Keir Starmer in a negative take on the 1993 D:Ream anthem that ushered in the last Labour government and the Northern Ireland band has now banned the party from using. It's one message from the Prime Minister the public fully believes in five months after Labour's landslide win.
Our latest Understanding Scotland Economy Tracker, the 13th 'wave' in the series, highlights a deepening pessimism among Scots, young and old, about their own and the country's prospects. Almost two-thirds (63%, up 9% on the August survey) believe the economy has worsened in the past year and 65% (up 13 points) expect a further deterioration. At a personal level, the sense of doom is slightly less dark: at 48%/44%. But don't hold your breath.
It's pretty plain that Scots, like most Brits, know and feel that the UK is measurably poorer now than it was, say, pre-pandemic or pre-Brexit or pre-great financial crisis even over a decade ago. The last parliament (2019-24) saw the worst decline in earnings growth for over 60 years and the "boomers'" children are worse off than their parents. Too many of these are now attracted to the Far Right - across Europe and elsewhere.
Sebastian Burnside, NatWest chief economist, told me at the tracker's launch (25 November) that he didn't expect a new recession but with Donald Trump already slapping prospective tariff hikes on Canada, Mexico and China it must be nip and tuck. A generalised tit-for-tat trade war will almost certainly deepen any recessionary tendencies, notably in the eurozone, with the ghost of Smoot Hawley 2.0 worrying the hell out of policymakers and observers. (Or it should be!)
Skipped meals and depression
Almost a half (47%) of younger Scots, according to our survey, say economic anxieties and pressures are affecting their mental health - a finding true of a third (32%) of Scots as a whole. Three in ten of us are losing sleep over our finances. People are cutting back on buying fresh food products and skipping meals (as many as 19%) and this is more true of young people than other demographic groups.
For me and others the greatest worry is the impact upon young children. Danny Dorling, Professor of Geography at Oxford University and a surprise guest at the launch, commented the worst affected in terms of the rise in child poverty in the Europe is England, he shocked us. No English county outperforms Scotland in this regard. In terms of economic pessimism, suggested this was a global trend - with some notable exceptions in countries such as India... and Russia - for other reasons.
This, of course, is no consolation. Around a quarter of a million of Scottish children (26%) live in relative poverty and the Scottish Government is way off reaching its 10% target by 2030-31, even with the Child Payment. We all need hope but our young people, above all children, need an injection of this most of all if we are to begin to tackle the enduring UK/Scottish problem of low productivity growth which, as Burnside said, is the biggest source of declining living standards.
Investing in the future
Rachel Reeves, the UK chancellor, is struggling to inject hope and optimism into business and consumers for all her talk of investment and growth. Our tracker, equally, sets a high bar for Shona Robison, finance secretary, to cross when she presents the Scottish Budget on December 4. Even the unexpected boost to the Scottish Government's net fiscal position from the first Reeves budget - "transformed" according to the IFS - may not be enough.
Robison, cannot promise the earth but she could and should offer the prospects of a (eventually) more stable outlook and put the emphasis on investment in education and training as well as in the most promising economic sectors, including the (struggling) creative industry. Our tracker points to an urgent need, above all, to restore public confidence in the future.
"Get Scotland Working" is likely to be a theme (h/t the UK version unveiled on November 26) for her to adopt. Not in terms of unemployment but incentives to enter or re-enter the labour market, notably among the more than 300,000 Scots on adult disability payment and those economically inactive as a whole (22.6% of the 16-64 age group) of which there are a staggering 9m in the UK.
However, for many work is not a route out of poverty or cutting the welfare bill, with around four in ten of those on Universal Credit in Scotland, being in work. Low paid and precarious work traps many in a constant battle to make ends meet - this certainly won’t help boost productivity with so many people losing sleep over their finances.
Collectively, Scottish politicians and civil society need to turn around what is one of the most arresting tracker findings: a net 64% of our citizens believe the economy works in the interests of the wealthy while a net -56% think it does not work for them individually.
