DHI responds to Resource Spending Review Framework
DHI responds to key questions from the Scottish Government’s 2022 Resource Spending Review consultation on spending priorities, the primary drivers of public spending, public sector workforce, equality, and achieving value from public sector spending.
Photo credit: George Clerk
The Scottish Government recently launched its first multi-year Resource Spending Review since 2011, outlining proposed spending plans on administration and the day-to-day delivery of services and programmes, such as school meals, concessionary bus passes and most public sector staff salaries.
In publishing the review framework, Scottish Government pledged to take an outcomes-focussed, evidence-based, and consultative approach to the review process, which it aims to complete by May 2022.
The David Hume Institute responded to questions on the spending priorities indicated by the review, the primary drivers of public spending, the public sector workforce, equality, and achieving value from public sector spending.
About our submission
DHI welcomed the opportunity to contribute to the review and our response drew on a number of our recent research projects. Broadly, we call on the Scottish Government to:
More clearly situate the Review Framework and its priorities within the overall context of Scotland’s existing National Performance Framework to focus on long term change
Prioritise cross-government collaboration including focusing on tackling tensions between different policy areas in addressing the Scottish Government’s priorities
Ensure demographic change is factored into resource spending and planning, including better recognising the contribution older people make to society and the economy
Revise its modelling of the impact of rising inflation, which is now likely to exceed previous estimates
Include climate change as a key driver of public spending, as well as being a resource spending priority
Use public procurement and planning policy as a means of prioritising long term gains to maximise the impact of public spending
Take action to radically shift to preventative spending, as suggested over 10 years ago by the Christie Commission
Improve equality by reforming local taxation
DHI recognises that the challenging economic conditions mean tough choices will need to be made. There is a need to be transparent about priorities and trade-offs. A mature debate will ensure that political point scoring doesn’t increase polarisation in society and negatively impact on the economy. We welcome the pragmatic cross-party approach and look forward to further conversation.
David Hume Institute gives evidence to Scottish Parliament committee
Susan Murray, Director of the David Hume Institute, gave evidence to the Scottish Parliament Finance and Public Administration committee following its response to the consultation on Public Finances in 2022-23.
Susan Murray, Director of the David Hume Institute, gave evidence to the Scottish Parliament Finance and Public Administration committee following its response to the consultation on Public Finances in 2022-23.
The Institute is calling for Scottish Government to:
Publish draft multi-year spending plans to help longer term planning for service improvement, investment and productivity, and increase transparency over forward planning.
Publish how it has prioritised for a fair and equal recovery, and provide underlying evidence for those priorities, recognising trade offs between shorter and longer term choices.
Link budget priorities to the National Performance Framework and the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals (UNSDGs), using them to analyse how the pandemic has affected some groups and communities worse than others. Continued use of the UNSDGs assists collaboration with other organisations and governments around the world.
Focus on climate action and a fair transition to net zero, faster delivery of digital infrastructure and measures to directly influence reductions in poverty and promote greater inclusivity.
Work to improve Scotland’s places by devolving resources and putting more power in the hands of local communities.
Ensure support for jobs where skills can be developed rather than skills development alone.
Commit to a full review of the Fiscal Framework which considers external changes including the loss of European Funding and new direct spending in Scotland from Westminster as well as the interactions between both devolved and reserved taxes and social securities.